The Landscape of Canadian Women's Crime Fiction

Canadian Women’s

Crime Fiction

My book project looks at mystery, suspense, and police procedural novels from L.R. Wright’s The Suspect to the present. I consider how authors ranging from Margaret Atwood and Alice Munro to Gail Bowen, Ausma Zehanat Khan, and Louise Penny use crime fiction to explore issues of gender, power, sexuality, and place.

History and Context

Canada has been a sovereign nation since 1867’s Confederation of the four original provinces. It is made up of ten provinces and three territories. We share the world’s longest undefended border with the United States, our long-time and valued ally. This relationship is under threat.

What is now Canada was established first as French and British colonies on the territories of Indigenous nations who, from coast to coast to coast, have lived on and used these lands since time immemorial. As many of the treaties of mutual respect and reciprocity promise, “as long as the grass grows green and the rivers run” the treaties will be upheld and the lands will be shared. We are all treaty people. The treaties have frequently been betrayed, but contemporary reconciliation processes and the legislative adoption of UNDRIP help offer a way forward.

All content is composed by Heidi Tiedemann Darroch, who holds a Creative Commons license for the material. It is expressly forbidden for the content to be used for generative AI purposes.

Copyeditor and designer: Liz Darroch

Crime Writers of Canada
Lək̓ʷəŋən Territories

  • On Winter Writing and Solitude and Nordic Noir

    This week I’m teaching Maggie Nelson’s Bluets, which is just about my favourite book; students will read only one excerpt from this poignant, tragi-comic, closely observed, skinny little book. So I hope that will be sufficient for them to see in Nelson what I see (and what so many see): the preeminent CNF author of…

  • On Teaching (and Not Teaching) True Crime in Creative Nonfiction

    My second CNF course is underway, and the class members are enthusiastic and engaged. We’ve just started the essay, both lyric and personal, and students are enjoying sharing their favourite David Sedaris pieces. But we’ve also just learned of a tragic death in our college community, and I’m feeling jolted back to last winter, when…

  • The Happy Hollisters, Trixie Belden, and Iconic Children’s Mystery Fiction

    When my daughter was seven, she had a brief (and for me, very welcome) phase of being interested in mystery fiction. In general, her tastes lie more with speculative/fantasy fiction. I blame her father. Marinating a young child in Doctor Who has consequences. But in Second Grade, when she homeschooled (briefly, because I am not…

Crime in a Cold Climate

Canadian crime fiction is an exciting national literature with substantial variations from its British, French, and American precursors. Like “Nordic Noir”, the term for suspense and thriller novels set in Scandinavia, Canadian mystery fiction has a strong sense of place.

Some other notable features: a complicated relationship to policing, including the RCMP (even in police procedurals); limited personal gun ownership (even by private investigators); extensive use of the genre to explore violence against women and feminist themes; prominent but frequently stereotyped Indigenous characters; liberal attitudes towards social issues, including gender equality, multiculturalism, and immigration.

History

Although Canada is a comparatively young country, with the 1867 Confederation having brought together only 4 of the current 10 provinces, its Indigenous roots date back more than 10 000 years.

Geography

Canadian crime fiction reflects the vastness of Canada–from sea to sea to sea. From east to west: Helen Escott, Natalie Carter-Giles, and Shelly Kawaja (NL); Anne Emery (NS); Louise Penny, Chrystine Brouillet, and Johanne Seymour (Quebec); Alison Gordon, Rosemary Aubert, and Maureen Jennings (Ontario); Gail Bowen (Saskatchewan). And so on.

Gender

Women dominate Canadian crime fiction, notwithstanding the significant achievements of prolific writers like Howard Engel, Giles Blunt, and the late and much-lamented Peter Robinson.

The books

From L.R. Wright’s Edgar-winning The Suspect to Louise Penny’s 2024 The Wolf, Canadian women’s crime fiction is extraordinarily diverse.

The writers

I’ll be adding short bio-bibliographic notes about the authors as I work my way from the west coast of British Columbia to Newfoundland, and up to the Arctic.

About me

I’m a college and university instructor and writer in Victoria, BC, an uninvited guest on the territories of the Lək̓ʷəŋən-speaking peoples, known today as the Songhees and Kosapsum Nations.